There’s something irresistible about a rotisserie chicken — the golden-brown skin, the savory aroma, and the convenience of a ready-to-eat meal. For busy families, seniors cooking for one, or anyone looking for a quick dinner solution, Walmart’s rotisserie chicken — usually around $4.98 — can seem like a budget-friendly choice. But is it really the bargain it appears to be?

The first thing to notice is size. Walmart’s chickens weigh about 1 pound 13 ounces, just shy of 2 pounds. That might be fine for one person, but for a family dinner or leftovers, the smaller bird can leave you wanting more. In comparison, Costco and Sam’s Club rotisserie chickens weigh around 3 pounds — nearly double the size — for almost the same price. The value per pound is clearly better at these warehouse clubs, even though Sam’s Club is owned by Walmart itself.

Flavor and juiciness also differ. Costco’s rotisserie chicken is consistently juicy and well-seasoned, often earning loyal fans who plan trips around buying it. Sam’s Club is similarly praised, with some shoppers claiming it surpasses Costco in taste. Walmart’s chicken, while serviceable, tends to fall short in both seasoning and moisture. The smaller size means less meat overall, and some customers report it can be dry compared to its warehouse competitors.

On paper, $4.98 sounds like a steal, but when factoring in size, flavor, and versatility, Costco and Sam’s Club clearly offer better value. If you’re feeding a family or want multiple meals from one purchase, choosing a bigger bird makes sense. Walmart’s version will still get dinner on the table, but for those seeking both savings and a tastier, juicier meal, bigger really is better.