Since my father-in-law passed away, my mother-in-law has expected my husband and me to pay for her birthday dinner every year without question. We always did, believing she needed the support. But everything changed when we accidentally discovered she had a secret retirement fund—money she never mentioned while continuing to ask us for financial help. Worse, we learned she had been quietly supporting my sister-in-law’s family with those savings. At her 90th birthday dinner, when the check arrived, my husband finally spoke up, telling her we would no longer cover the cost and that we knew she had been taking advantage of us. When he asked why his sister received help but he did not, she broke down in tears and blamed me for turning him against her.

Now she’s demanding an apology, and the family is divided. I stood by my husband because I believe marriage requires unity, but I can’t shake the guilt of watching an elderly woman cry at her own birthday dinner. At the same time, years of quiet resentment have built up from giving without appreciation or honesty. I believe parents should treat their children fairly, and financial boundaries are necessary—even with family. Still, I wonder if there was a gentler way to handle it. Was standing my ground the right choice, or did we cross a line we can’t come back from?