Jacob Elordi’s latest movie has given fans plenty to discuss after The Dog Stars, directed by Ridley Scott, opened in U.S. theaters with roughly $8 million. The disappointing start quickly sparked online speculation because Elordi has been linked romantically with Kendall Jenner. Some social media users revived the long-running “Kardashian curse” theory, suggesting that celebrities who date members of the Kardashian-Jenner family somehow experience career setbacks. The idea has circulated for more than a decade, particularly around professional athletes and entertainers connected to the family. But there is no evidence that such a curse exists, and a movie’s box-office performance can depend on many factors, including competition, marketing, audience interest and reviews. Still, the timing was enough for fans to connect the dots and debate whether Elordi could be the latest name added to the growing list.

The theory has been associated with several Kardashian relationships over the years, including those involving NBA players Lamar Odom, Tristan Thompson and Ben Simmons. Some former partners have discussed the intense media attention surrounding their relationships, but that is very different from proving a mysterious curse. There are also plenty of examples that challenge the theory, including Kendall’s former boyfriend Devin Booker, who reached the NBA Finals while they were together. Kendall herself rejected the narrative during the 2021 Keeping Up With the Kardashians reunion, arguing that men should take responsibility for their own careers rather than blaming the women they date. As for Elordi, one disappointing opening weekend does not define his career. The actor remains one of Hollywood’s most recognizable young stars, and whether The Dog Stars finds a larger audience in the weeks ahead is something fans will simply have to watch.