A new development in the case of Charlie Kirk’s killing suggests a potential political motive. Utah County Attorney Jeff Gray revealed that Tyler Robinson, 22, allegedly left a note for his transgender roommate stating, “I had the opportunity to take out Charlie Kirk and I’m going to take it.” In accompanying messages, Robinson expressed frustration over what he perceived as hatred from Kirk. Following the news, prominent conservatives pushed back on claims that Robinson was connected to any right-wing political movements.

Instead, they pointed to rhetoric from the political left, arguing that years of inflammatory language about conservatives could have contributed to the violence. The debate spilled over into mainstream media, particularly during an intense exchange on Fox News’ The Five. Co-host Greg Gutfeld strongly opposed attempts by fellow panelist Jessica Tarlov to frame the issue as part of a broader trend involving political violence from both sides. Gutfeld emphasized that Kirk’s case was distinct in terms of motive and public attention.

Tarlov referenced other incidents of violence against Democratic figures, but Gutfeld rejected comparisons. He argued that figures like Kirk had been heavily targeted in public discourse prior to their deaths, which he believes contributes to a hostile environment. Gutfeld went on to assert that radical ideologies and divisive rhetoric can influence individuals to commit acts of violence. He claimed Robinson had been influenced by extreme online narratives and ideas, which he said can devalue human life and morality.

While Tarlov maintained that she wasn’t downplaying Kirk’s death, Gutfeld insisted that the conversation needed to move beyond “both sides” arguments. He concluded by stating that the focus should be on accountability and rejecting ideologies that incite violence.