Rebecca’s mother-in-law, Patricia, never liked her stepson Noah and often made subtle digs. For Rebecca and Eric’s anniversary, Patricia unexpectedly offered to babysit Noah overnight. Rebecca felt uneasy but agreed. Later that night, Noah tearfully called, insisting he “didn’t do it.” When they rushed back, Patricia accused Noah of ruining her mattress and demanded $1,500 for a replacement. Though Noah swore he was innocent, Rebecca reluctantly paid.

Two days later, Eric’s sister, Claire, revealed the shocking truth: Patricia’s cat had been peeing on the mattress for months. Patricia had planned the entire setup to make Rebecca pay for a new one, blaming Noah to get what she wanted. Rebecca kept quiet, waiting for the right moment to expose her.

At a family dinner, Patricia publicly shamed Noah, prompting Rebecca to reveal Claire’s confession. The family was horrified, and Eric confronted his mother, who weakly admitted partial guilt. Furious, Eric declared Patricia would never be alone with Noah again, and they stormed out, supported by other family members.

Patricia eventually returned the money but offered no apology. The family went low-contact, and Eric defended Noah fiercely, calling him “the son I always wanted.” Months later, Rebecca felt grateful for her loving husband and son, as they prepared to welcome another baby into their growing family.