On September 20, 2025, Meghan Markle and Prince Harry attended the One805Live! benefit concert for first responders at Kevin Costner’s exclusive Santa Barbara polo field. While the event was meant to honor local heroes, Meghan’s $2,490 Carolina Herrera halterneck dress stole the spotlight, sparking a heated online debate. Some fans praised her beauty, while others criticized the dress for being wrinkled, ill-fitting, and unflattering.

Critics focused on the dress’s style, with comments about its wide-shouldered cut and loose fit near the chest. Some even compared Meghan unfavorably to former First Lady Melania Trump, who had recently worn a striking yellow Carolina Herrera gown to a royal state banquet in Windsor Castle hosted by King Charles III. Melania’s look, however, wasn’t universally praised either, with some saying her gown felt out of place and inappropriate for the formal event.

Social media reactions to Melania’s ensemble were just as divided. While some admired her bold style, others mocked the gown’s color and unusual pink belt, with a few comparing her to a “banana.” Fashion expert Marian Kwei noted that although Melania’s look was daring, it technically adhered to royal protocol, which requires women to wear full-length ball gowns at state banquets.

In the end, both Meghan and Melania became the center of fashion controversies in the same week. Meghan’s California-chic look clashed with public expectations, while Melania’s daring royal banquet gown pushed the boundaries of tradition, proving once again that royal fashion choices are rarely just about clothes.