My husband and I were stunned when our 19-year-old daughter casually mentioned that her new boyfriend was 42. That’s a 23-year age gap — older than she’s ever dated before, though, apparently, not by much. She insists he’s kind, respectful, and makes her feel “understood in a way no one else has.” But all we can see is a man well into middle age dating someone barely out of high school. While she assures us it’s a healthy relationship, my instincts scream otherwise. We’ve tried to stay calm, not wanting to push her further away, but the situation makes us deeply uneasy.

Now she wants us to meet him. My husband flat-out refuses, saying he can’t sit across from a man who could’ve been her teacher — or worse, her father. I’m torn. Part of me wants to understand what she sees in him, maybe even assess whether he’s manipulating her. But another part worries that agreeing to meet him sends the wrong message — that we accept this as normal. We’re walking a tightrope: wanting to protect her while not damaging our relationship beyond repair. We need to decide soon… before the distance between us grows too wide.