The subway car fell unusually quiet when people noticed the biker. He was big, dressed in leather, covered in tattoos — and openly crying while holding a small dog wrapped in a worn blanket. One by one, passengers shifted away, clutching their bags and whispering, as if grief itself were something dangerous. I stayed where I was, unable to look away, because the way he cradled that dog — gently, protectively — told a very different story than his appearance suggested. It felt like witnessing a goodbye that wasn’t meant to be public, yet unfolded right there between rattling tracks and flickering lights.

The dog was clearly near the end. Its breathing was shallow, its body still except for the occasional weak movement of its tail. When someone nearby muttered that security should be called, the biker didn’t react. He was focused only on the dog, whispering reassurances and promises that he wouldn’t be alone. Eventually, I crossed the empty space between us and sat down. That’s when he told me the truth: the dog had cancer, only hours left. He couldn’t bear the idea of saying goodbye in a sterile room, so he chose one last journey instead — a subway ride to Coney Island, the place where they first found each other more than a decade earlier.